This outdated method of selecting leaders should have no place in a modern, independent country choosing its elected officials. Leadership selection must respect individual freedom, not pressure citizens to reveal their political preferences publicly. The recent SPLM primary election raises serious questions about South Sudan’s democratic development and its ability to conduct credible, free, and fair elections.
There are five reasons why this approach risks deepening divisions.
1. It undermines individual freedom. When citizens line up publicly behind candidates, they may feel compelled to follow chiefs, elders, or influential political figures. Those supporting different candidates may fear being labeled disloyal. A secret ballot protects individual choice and allows citizens to vote according to their conscience without fear of judgment or retaliation.
2. It reinforces tribal and communal divisions. Public displays of political support can turn elections into contests between clans, ethnic groups, and regions. Instead of evaluating candidates based on qualifications, integrity, and policies, people may face pressure to support someone because of shared identity. Such practices risk weakening national unity and reinforcing existing divisions.
3. It creates opportunities for intimidation. Publicly identifiable political preferences can expose individuals to threats, discrimination, or retaliation. In a country affected by political instability and insecurity, protecting citizens from coercion is essential. Elections should encourage participation, not force people to demonstrate political loyalty in front of their communities.
4. It undermines confidence in election results. A public lineup does not necessarily reflect genuine consent. Some people may follow the crowd or influential figures rather than express their actual preferences. Without transparent procedures, independent monitoring, and credible vote counting, candidates and their supporters may question the legitimacy of the outcome, potentially increasing political tensions.
5. It raises concerns about democratic readiness. South Sudan gained independence in 2011, but its first general elections have been repeatedly postponed. Freedom House’s 2026 assessment rated the country Not Free, reflecting significant restrictions on political rights and civil liberties. These challenges make it particularly important to establish transparent, accountable, and credible electoral institutions before nationwide elections take place.
The way forward is to institutionalize secret ballots, independent electoral oversight, transparent counting, effective dispute resolution, and civic education. Political parties must demonstrate their commitment to democratic principles through their own internal processes before asking citizens to trust them with national leadership.
South Sudan needs leaders chosen through genuine consent, not citizens pressured to demonstrate loyalty to powerful individuals. Democracy begins when every person can make a political choice freely, safely, and without fear.
What I see in the SPLM primaries raises a fundamental question: if political parties cannot adequately protect individual choice within their own selection processes, how can citizens confidently expect those principles to be upheld in national elections?
Democracy is not measured by how publicly citizens demonstrate loyalty to leaders, but by how freely they can choose them.